I have just finished reading The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien. This is my first reading of the work as an adult (I read it twice as a child.), and I must say that it was a journey well worth the undertaking. I am sure that this post will add nothing to the utmost respect and merited fame which Tolkien already possesses in our time. However, for myself, I wish to put down a few words of tribute for this modern author of genius, and to bestow upon him some small honor in gratitude for his epic work.
But enough with the hero-worship. Why has Tolkien gathered such praise and cult-like adoration for his work of The Lord of the Rings? If you are asking this question, it is most likely because you have not read the books for yourself. I would have a difficult time relating to or understanding someone who cannot appreciate this fantasy masterpiece. The Lord of the Rings is not so much a classic for its fantastic and imaginative world of elves, dwarves, hobbits, and orcs, but rather for its impeccable ability to strike at the core of man’s soul and inspire it to magnanimity. Since you can read any number of books already dedicated to the subject of Tolkien and his works, let me simply reduce my commentary to a few concise bullet points which highlight why the Tolkien-cult may be well founded.
1. Tolkien is a brilliant author and poet.
Really. You will have a difficult time falling in love with books like The Hunger Games or Twilight after reading Tolkien. His way of crafting literature is comparable to the formation of music by a master like Bach. One may dislike Bach or Tolkien, but no one could legitimately criticize either for being a poor artist. Tolkien’s vivid descriptions of Middle Earth capture the imagination of the reader in an unparalleled manner. Tolkien, the philologist and philosopher, shows his mastery both of language and his understanding of the human experience through his graceful and fluent ability to manipulate, excite, and capture our imaginations in his writing. He did, after all, create an entirely new language (Elvish) as the foundation for his novel. I am truly embarrassed by attempting to write anything at all after reading his work.
Tolkien is hard not to love with his simple down-to-earth manner of writing. His books possess a great amount of profundity and deep philosophical and theological allegory, and yet he never fails to integrate a simple and humble quality which preserves a welcome element of realism. He strikes a perfect balance between intellectual loftiness and earthy humor. One way Tolkien achieves this is through utilizing the comical, short, insignificant yet relateable hobbit creatures as the central protagonists of his tale.
3. Tolkien artfully exposes the most fundamental drama and plight of man.
Tolkien’s work is not simply about a magical ring, elves and bad guys. The Lord of the Rings is ultimately not about a dark lord or ring at all. The work subtly exposes the struggle man faces in his encounter with the world, the flesh, and the devil. Ultimately,Tolkien’s world is about man’s plight for redemption and salvation. And yet, Tolkien does not use the obvious allegories that his friend, C.S. Lewis, employed in his Chronicles of Narnia. While the latter author unabashedly paralleled Bible stories in his fantasy works (e.g. Aslan as an allegory for Christ), Tolkien is much more subtle in his integration of philosophical and theological themes. Tolkien’s works inspire both Christians and non-Christians in a way that may greatly surpass Lewis’ fiction. Tolkien uses a more “classical” style, more reminiscent to the ancient pagan epics of Homer rather than to the modern Christian Milton. But Tolkien’s work is nonetheless orthodox in its adherence to Christian philosophy. The character of Gollum does not directly parallel any person in the Scriptures, but Gollum does uncannily incarnate any one who is suffering from addiction or subject to the powerful grip of vice. The ring most definitely embodies the very essence of evil and sin, something which is truly alluring yet ultimately poisonous, deadly, and enslaving.
Finally, the proof of The Lord of the Rings’ greatness is ultimately only found in the personal encounter one has when entering into the mystery of Middle Earth. I find that reading this classic dissipates my usual dry cynicism and depression. It awakens and inflames in me a transcendent spirit of courage, nobility, and wonder. I feel a longing to take up a sword or bow and fight in the defense of Middle Earth. Then I remember that such a war really does exist in this life and that I must respond to its happening. The fight that Gollum and Frodo have in resisting the lure of of the One Ring is really the same struggle I have in resisting the passions of my own flesh and addictions. There is also found the exterior war. Just as the evil Sauron poured out his forces to crush the civilized world of Gondor, so too I experience the ever darkening culture around me which promotes the destruction of life, family, and “common sense” principles. I feel a renewed call to reject my apathy and to fight in the defense of life, family, and freedom.
Such is my phenomenological defense of Tolkien as a masterful author. He has the singular ability to work his way into my mind, heart, and soul and to draw from these the highest of aspirations.
But c’mon…You want me to spoil all of this awesomeness? Stop reading my stream of consciousness and pick up The Lord of the Rings; I dare you to enter onto this quest for yourself and to see where this journey may lead you.